Maximizers and Satisficers: Twenty-Four Years of Testing a Signature Claim in Psychology
At the end of Barry Schwartz’s July 2005 TEDGlobal talk in Oxford, he delivered a widely quoted line: “The secret to happiness is low expectations.” The talk has racked up nearly 20 million views on the official platform, cementing the popular notion that maximizers make themselves miserable chasing the absolute best while satisficers are happier settling for good enough. Yet if you check the transcript of that talk, neither term ever appears.
The familiar distinction comes from a 2002 paper by Schwartz and colleagues and his 2004 bestseller The Paradox of Choice. For more than two decades, “don’t be a maximizer—learn to stop at good enough” has been standard gospel in career and lifestyle advice.
Subsequent empirical research in psychology and decision science, however, shows that holding high standards does not make people unhappy in itself. The real culprits are endless searching and persistent indecision.
Origins of the Concept: How Simon’s Decision Rule Became a Psychometric Trait
“Satisficing” was first proposed by Nobel laureate in economics Herbert Simon, and its original meaning looked very different from what later entered pop psychology.
In his seminal 1955 and 1956 papers, Simon pointed out that the “fully rational agent” assumed by traditional economics requires information and computational capacity that real organisms simply do not possess.
Under bounded rationality, real decision-makers rely on setting an “acceptability threshold” and halt their search as soon as they find an option that meets their aspiration level. Simon borrowed the dialect word satisfice to describe this mechanism for meeting needs under environmental constraints.
This framework has three defining features:
- It is a decision rule, not a personality trait: Simon was analyzing a general strategy used by constrained organisms facing complex environments, not sorting people into two fixed types.
- Satisficing is not passive settling: Simon showed that a selection mechanism with a dynamically adjusted aspiration level can, once search costs are factored in, be equivalent to optimal choice over the long run.
- Optimization is the enemy of satisficing: Voltaire famously wrote that “the best is the enemy of the good.” Late in his career, Simon inverted and recast that aphorism as “Optimization is the enemy of satisficing”—fixating on a theoretical global optimum undermines genuinely satisfactory decisions in practice.
The pivot came in 2002. Schwartz and his coauthors recast Simon’s decision rule as an individual trait—arguing that some people naturally strive for “the best” (maximizers) while others lean toward “good enough” (satisficers)—and built a scale to argue that maximizing tendencies directly erode personal well-being.
The Original Empirical Evidence: The Gap Between Objective Success and Subjective Distress
Schwartz’s 13-item Maximization Scale, published in 2002, launched two decades of empirical research. Yet looking closely at the foundational literature reveals several facts that popular summaries routinely overlook.
The 2002 research consisted entirely of cross-sectional correlational studies (measured at a single point in time, making causal direction impossible to determine), and measured no objective achievement outcomes whatsoever.
The paper did find positive correlations between maximization scores and higher regret () and depressive tendencies (), but the negative correlation with happiness was actually modest (around pooled), and there was no longitudinal evidence establishing causality. The correlation coefficient ranges from to ; the larger its absolute value, the more strongly two phenomena move together.
It was not until 2006 that Iyengar, Wells, and Schwartz published a longitudinal job-search study in Psychological Science tracking 548 graduating college seniors, quantifying “objective outcomes” for the first time: maximizers landed starting salaries averaging $44,515, significantly higher than satisficers’ $37,085—nearly 20% more pay ($7,430 per year).
Subjectively, however, maximizers reported significantly lower satisfaction with the jobs they landed. Further analysis showed that even after controlling for salary, this satisfaction gap persisted and was fully driven by fixating on unrealized options and regret over having so many choices (a statistical pattern known as a mediation effect). As the researchers put it:
Even when they get what they want, maximizers can still look back afterward and repeatedly second-guess whether an even better option was out there. — Sheena Iyengar et al. (2006)
Dissecting the Scale: High Standards Are Blameless; the Pain Comes from Searching and Agonizing
Starting in 2008, psychologists began examining the construct validity of the 2002 scale—asking what the instrument was actually measuring. Analyzing data from more than 5,800 participants, Nenkov et al. established that the original scale conflated three distinct components:
- High Standards: Holding demanding expectations for outcomes and life in general. Empirically, this component shows no link whatsoever to depression or unhappiness (and in certain contexts even correlates positively with well-being); instead, it correlates positively with “need for cognition” (how much someone enjoys effortful thinking).
- Alternative Search: Repeatedly comparing external options and struggling to stop looking. Negatively correlated with well-being and optimism, it is a primary driver of exhaustion and regret.
- Decision Difficulty: Experiencing hesitation, stress, and distress when facing choices. Strongly and negatively correlated with life satisfaction.
Diab et al. (2008) went further, showing that when researchers use a revised instrument that strips out decision-difficulty items—the Maximization Tendency Scale (MTS)—the correlations of maximizing tendencies with neuroticism and life satisfaction vanish completely. In other words, maintaining high standards is harmless on its own; the psychological toll comes primarily from endlessly searching through options and internal friction while deciding.
Subsequent cross-cultural work (Roets et al., 2012) also showed that in a Chinese sample, the negative correlation between maximization and well-being disappeared. And in workplace studies, how well maximization predicts job performance depends heavily on which scale is used (Giacopelli et al., 2013)—hardly the blanket negative impact that pop psychology assumes.
Empirical Convergence After 24 Years: The 2022 Meta-Analysis
In 2022, Belli et al. published a multilevel meta-analysis (a statistical method that pools results across multiple studies to compute an overall estimate) in the Journal of Consumer Psychology spanning 108 papers and 47,245 participants, yielding four clear conclusions:
- Divergent component effects: The overall correlation between high standards and well-being is near zero (mean ), and in certain decision contexts it even turns positive. The well-being deficit is driven almost entirely by alternative search () and decision difficulty (, nearly twice the negative impact of alternative search).
- The amplifying effect of external feedback: When an environment is saturated with rankings, social comparison, and other external feedback, the psychological downside of maximizing is three times as large as in no-feedback settings ( vs. ).
- Choice-set size does not drive the deficit: Statistical analysis showed that the number of available options has no significant effect on maximizers’ well-being deficit. This finding directly challenges the central premise of The Paradox of Choice: the distress does not come from having too many options, but from a comparison mechanism spinning out of control.
- Dynamic adjustment works: A preregistered experiment (where hypotheses and analysis plans are publicly filed before the study begins to prevent cherry-picking results afterward) by Kamiya et al. (2021) demonstrated that an intervention prompting people to deliberately “lower their target level” effectively reduces post-decision regret—especially among those inclined to maximize.
The Satisficer’s Blind Spot: How Mediocrity Gets Institutionalized
Popular advice that unconditionally celebrates “stopping at good enough” tends to overlook the strategy’s own built-in cost.
In their 1963 classic A Behavioral Theory of the Firm, Cyert and March brought satisficing into organizational decision-making: firms typically set an acceptability threshold and trigger “problemistic search” only when actual performance falls below aspiration levels.
The flaw in this mechanism is clear: as long as the status quo clears the minimum bar, the organization has no impetus to improve, and mediocrity becomes institutionalized.
The same dynamic plays out in personal decisions. By settling too early, a decision-maker forfeits the chance to discover potentially optimal solutions. Whether a strategy pays off depends on the decision context:
| Decision Context | Recommended Strategy | Potential Cost Type | Core Consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| High-stakes & irreversible (e.g., career moves, key partners) | Maximizing search + explicit threshold | Process cost (time spent searching and comparing) | Avoid premature settling that locks in long-term mediocrity |
| High-frequency & reversible (e.g., daily purchases, tool selection) | Satisficing (good enough) | Outcome cost (missing minor marginal gains) | Cut off decision difficulty and mental drain |
A maximizer’s costs are booked to the process (time spent searching, mental fatigue), while a satisficer’s costs are booked to the outcome (potentially missing out on significantly better options). The two strategies allocate their costs differently; which is heavier depends on how accurately the threshold is calibrated and how fast the environment shifts. When the same choice recurs over time, balancing reliable known options against continued exploration follows the explore-exploit trade-off.
NOTE
Further reading: Stick with the Old Favorite or Try Something New? Life’s Explore-Exploit Dilemma Through the Lens of Slot Machines
Optimal Stopping Theory: The Mathematics of Dynamic Thresholds
In applied mathematics and statistics, optimal stopping theory shows that Simon’s satisficing principle rests on rigorous mathematical footing.
In the classic “Secretary Problem,” candidates are interviewed sequentially, and every rejection is final. The mathematically proven globally optimal strategy is to observe and reject the first of candidates (, where is Euler’s number) solely to establish a benchmark, and then hire the first candidate who outperforms everyone seen so far.
0 37% 100%
|-------- 1 --------|--------------- 2 ---------------|
1 Observation (37%): Observe, don't hire; set benchmark
2 Selection (63%): Hire the first who beats the benchmark
This model highlights a crucial point: even the mathematically optimal strategy for finding a global best is, at bottom, a threshold rule that sets a stop-loss.
In more advanced models of search theory, when every step of searching carries a cost in time and effort, the optimal strategy goes even further: it requires the decision-maker to dynamically lower their reservation price (their minimum acceptable threshold).
Put side by side, what psychology measures as the trouble with maximizing corresponds in the mathematical model not to “striving for excellence,” but to setting the threshold too high and refusing to revise it downward as search costs mount—an aspiration level detached from the actual distribution of options, where search costs keep piling up yet the searcher never stops, spinning their wheels indefinitely.
A Practical Decision Framework: Five Dynamic Criteria
Bringing together the conceptual history, the psychometric breakdown, and the mathematical models yields five actionable decision criteria:
- Allocate exploration effort by stakes and reversibility: Major, irreversible decisions (such as career pivots or key partnerships) justify upfront exploration to establish a strict threshold. High-frequency, reversible everyday choices call for straightforward satisficing.
- Manage your comparison environment rather than suppressing high standards: As the meta-analytic evidence shows, distress comes primarily from the comparison process rather than personal standards. Deliberately tuning out social-media rankings and gratuitous peer comparisons reduces psychological strain far more effectively than forcing yourself to lower your standards.
- Maximize on outputs, satisfice on tools: Maintain high standards for your own work and professional output (the harmless component), while adopting a good-enough approach when choosing tools, workflows, and peripheral resources (cutting off decision difficulty).
- Set a search budget and lower the threshold dynamically: Define an explicit search budget (in time or number of options) before you begin. When marginal costs climb or market feedback falls short of expectations, revising your threshold downward is a rational correction aligned with optimal stopping theory.
- Once you commit, cut off counterfactual comparisons: The moment a decision is locked in, stop entertaining “what if I had chosen the other path” scenarios so you do not get trapped in the mental drain of unrealized options.
Conclusion: Optimization Is the Enemy of Satisficing
Looking back across twenty-four years of empirical research, holding high standards does not make people unhappy. The trouble starts when thresholds refuse to budge as search costs accumulate and conditions change.
The aphorism Herbert Simon left behind late in life when he rewrote Voltaire—“Optimization is the enemy of satisficing”—still holds true today: set clear standards on choices that matter, lower your threshold when exploration runs over budget, and stop comparing once your criteria are met, so high standards never turn into relentless mental drain.